iCliniq logo

Ask a Doctor Online Now

HomeAnswersAyurveda SpecialistpalpitationsWhich is better ayurveda or allopathy for palpitation?

Is ayurveda better than allopathy for palpitations?

The following is an actual conversation between an iCliniq user and a doctor that has been reviewed and published as a Premium Q&A.

Medically reviewed by

iCliniq medical review team

Published At December 27, 2019
Reviewed AtJune 3, 2024

Patient's Query

Hello doctor,

I am a 25-years-male. Two months back, I got into a very fearful situation and I felt panicked at that time. I consulted a psychiatrist and he gave me Clonezopam, Propranolol, and anti-depressants. After using it for seven to ten days I stopped them by knowing that they are addictive. And after stopping I felt new kind of problems such as heart palpitations whenever I try to sleep in the daytime and I get irregular sleep at night, feeling anxious. For many days I kept tolerating them, after many days now the symptoms have diminished but still, I get palpitations whenever I try to sleep, then I took Medhavati for 12-14 days. My sleeping time at night somewhat increased but I did not use to get a refreshed sleep.

I consulted a general doctor, and he told me it is just a phobia and gave me Stalopam (Clonezepam and Escitalopram) for 15 days and multivitamins tablets. Then I consulted an ayurvedic specialist, he gave Manasamitra vatakam, Stresswin, and Saraswatiristam. Please help me with whether I should take these ayurvedic medicines or take antidepressants for 15 days. Are Manasamitra and Saraswatiristam safe for me and do not have side effects? And what time does it take to show effects and for much duration should I take them? Now I am almost fine but unable to sleep at the daytime due to palpitations and getting some negative fearful thoughts at some times. Does Manasamitra increase serotonin in the brain and give enthusiasm? I am thinking of going for allopathy for 15 days or will Ayurveda medicines show early results? Please help.

Answered by Dr. Arul Amuthan L


Welcome to icliniq.com.

I could understand how much confusion you experience and your mental pain. So far, fewer studies have been done if we combine allopathy drugs with Ayurveda or Siddha drugs. In your case, I feel you should continue the allopathy drugs for 15 days (or above as per the physician's instruction). I feel you can also have Propranolol to reduce the palpitation. You can continue the allopathy drugs for particular days. In order to avoid addiction, the gradual (stepwise dose reduction) reduction of tablets should be followed. For example: from day 16th onwards, half tablet to be continued for the next week, then every alternate day half tablet for the next week, then every 4th day half a tablet for the next week, then stop it. This can be done with the advice of the physician. Few research in animals has proved that Manasamitra tablet could increase serotonin levels, but no 100 % guarantee was given. Many clinical sharing conclude that these three ayurvedic drugs are useful if the patient starts the therapy in the early stage of the disease. And also good for long-term treatment. Hence, in your case adding these drugs will surely have some beneficial role.

You do not stop these Ayurvedic drugs, continue it for the next six months. You join a regular yoga class or training class (daily continuously) for the next six months. In my experience, after six months, you can stop all medications including Ayurveda, and can run the best life only with yoga practice. Yoga practice at home is free of cost. Many people got miracle relief from anxiety, and depression and can focus on their studies or business, or particular work, with good sleep and a good diet. You find out your interested hobby. Be it plants, pets, colored fishes, walking, playing, picnic, temples, etc. Focus on these. You will come out of the stressful anxiety.

I hope this helps.

Patient's Query

Thank you doctor,

I have not started taking Ayurvedic medicines till now, but how much time does this Manasamitra, Saraswatiristam, and Stresswin take to show effect? Are these as quick as that allopathy medicine or these will take more time? Are these prescribed medicines correct for me and safe? I sometimes feel like I do not have anything but sometimes I get easily worried and get upset about small things. Sometimes I think I do not need any medicines at all and I will get cured automatically as I have made progress in my health.

I recently got some kind of negative fearful thought so again I thought of taking medicine and as I have to go to another place for education purposes next month. I do not again want to get into this kind of situation. I thought of using medicines before I go. So is it better for me to take medicines or not at all take any medicines, leave it to cure automatically? Before I did not have any kind of anxiety problems, I just used to get some sweating, and breathing problems whenever I hear very bad news and at normal times I would be alright and perfect. Please give me your valuable opinion. Sometimes I am getting excessive saliva in my mouth. What could be the reason?

Answered by Dr. Arul Amuthan L


Welcome back to iclinq.com.

In psychiatry conditions, very rarely the disease persists always. Most of the time, this is periodic or occurs after some stimulation, provocation, or randomly. Hence, one cannot think that the disease is completely cured as the symptoms are solved now. It requires a holistic therapy in which drugs, family, and friends care, improving the economy and education in students, psychology counseling etc. Ideally, one need not take the drug continuously, it can be taken only during the appearance of symptoms. Unfortunately, we do not realize that it is the disease's symptoms, hence do not consult a physician. If you are more positive, you can immediately approach the nearby physician, where ever you are, and follow their drugs. It will not cure automatically. You need mental and physical support. My additional advice is to consult a psychology counselor, who will train you to overcome. Also, start yoga and pranayama practice. These two will make you live happily without drugs. This is my personal advice.

For immediate control of symptoms, please continue the allopathy drugs. These Ayurvedic drugs are correct for this condition, but it will take a minimum of two weeks to show minimal results. The improvement will be a comparatively long period even after stopping the drug. Hence, it is good for the prophylaxis of future symptoms. It is not necessary to take Ayurvedic drugs for this condition. If you consume also, it will take two weeks to show a beneficial effect. It is up to you. The excess salivation is due to parasympathetic activity. This activity is excess due to some sour foods or drugs or psychological factors like happiness, thinking about some interesting food or flavor, etc. There are some drugs (anticholinergic drugs) we use to reduce salivation. It is usually given before surgery to reduce salivation during surgery. If your salivation is continuous and disturbing, then think about drugs. Otherwise, just ignore it.

Same symptoms don't mean you have the same problem. Consult a doctor now!

Dr. Arul Amuthan L
Dr. Arul Amuthan L


Community Banner Mobile
By subscribing, I agree to iCliniq's Terms & Privacy Policy.

Ask your health query to a Wellness Expert online

Ayurveda Specialist

*guaranteed answer within 4 hours

Disclaimer: No content published on this website is intended to be a substitute for professional medical diagnosis, advice or treatment by a trained physician. Seek advice from your physician or other qualified healthcare providers with questions you may have regarding your symptoms and medical condition for a complete medical diagnosis. Do not delay or disregard seeking professional medical advice because of something you have read on this website. Read our Editorial Process to know how we create content for health articles and queries.

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. iCliniq privacy policy